top of page

A Practical Guide to Auditing Your Messaging for Unearned Claims

Tom Buttle
Jun 8
2 min read

Most businesses aren't consciously exaggerating in their marketing, but most brand messaging, looked at honestly, carries more claims than the business can currently prove. It's rarely deliberate. It's gradual, with a line added during a rebrand and a few more from a copywriter reaching for impact, and nobody ever goes back to check whether the whole thing still holds together.


Messaging accumulates because few businesses sit down and design their entire set of claims from a blank page. Positioning statements build up over years. Layered by different people at different points - with nobody actually tasked with removing what no longer fits - the result is a body of messaging that reads well line by line while collectively promising more than the business delivers.


That's expensive in a specific way, since every unearned claim is a risk sitting there waiting for a sceptical customer to test it, and when they do, the damage doesn't stay contained to that one line. It colours how credible everything else you say looks.


Running the audit


It's a straightforward exercise even if the conversation it prompts isn't always comfortable. Take every substantive claim across your core messaging, from the website to sales collateral to pitch decks to LinkedIn. For each one ask what specific, checkable evidence exists that this is true. Not "we believe it's true," not "it was true a few years ago," but current, provable evidence a sceptical prospect could actually go and find.

Claims tend to sort into three piles once you test them this way. Some hold up cleanly, backed by data or case studies. Some are directionally true but overstated. Others are aspirational, meaning things you'd like to be true, dressed up as present-tense fact.


What to do with each pile


Keep the first pile and make it louder and more specific, since these are your genuine proof points. Recalibrate the second, because the underlying truth is usually still valuable and just needs honest framing. The third pile is the hardest to act on, since cutting a claim can feel like admitting weakness, but in practice it's the opposite. A shorter list of claims that are all demonstrably true persuades harder than a longer list a sceptical reader can't fully trust.


That's the whole logic behind "say less, mean more." A prospect who can quickly verify a claim through a case study, a specific number or a named example trusts you fast, while a prospect who hits a generic, unfalsifiable claim does the opposite, even if they couldn't tell you exactly why. Precision reads as confidence, and breadth without evidence reads as padding.


Because messaging accumulates gradually, this isn't a one-off project. It's worth building the audit into an annual review, ideally alongside whoever owns your case studies and proof points, so new claims only get added once there's real evidence behind them.


The most persuasive messaging out there is rarely the longest. It's the shortest list of claims that all happen to be true.


 
 
bottom of page